Movies of 2016
Well, Concussion arrived at the movie theatres last year, but it was my first movie to watch this year.
My initial reactions were posted on my Livejournal, but moving on to yours...?
My initial reactions were posted on my Livejournal, but moving on to yours...?
Comments
SPOILERS
One thing I found very effective was a bit of misdirection Sorrentino uses. Caine's wife evidently died about 10 years ago, a loss which first gets mentioned in passing (he used to come to this hotel with her, his daughter chides him for not even taking flowers to her) then becomes an important bit of characterization, explaining why Caine refuses to come out of retirement for a concert requested by the Queen: the piece she wants to hear was written specifically for his wife to sing. Near the end, he does as his daughter asked... and visits his wife, who is alive but suffering advanced degenerative dementia, a vacant shell. All the usual euphemistic metaphors that evaded saying that she's dead... weren't. It isn't an everything-you-know-is-wrong twist, but it's a surprise which gives an added layer of tragedy to the story. I don't know if it would be as effective for someone who hasn't experienced something like that with someone they loved, but it hit home for me.
The Keitel storyline also has a surprise ending, but it's less a matter of foreshadowing with a twist, and more just an unexpected reversal: he's enthusiastically writing what he plans to be the great last film of his career, but the actress upon whom it depends – a matron of cinema whom he originally "discovered" – shows up to tell him she won't be doing it, killing the whole project. He and his team of young protegés have been struggling to write the deathbed scene which ends the film, and he finally gives up. And kills himself.
(The conclusion of the film isn't quite that grim: Caine relents and does the concert for the Queen, moving on in a way that Keitel couldn't.)